Brief Review — A Comprehensive Survey on Heart Sound Analysis in the Deep Learning Era

Overview of Heart Sound Classification Using Deep Learning

Sik-Ho Tsang
3 min readMar 17, 2024
Heart Sound Classification

A Comprehensive Survey on Heart Sound Analysis in the Deep Learning Era
HSC Using DL Overview
, by Leibniz University Hannover, Imperial College London, Griffith University, Beijing Institute of Technology, University of Augsburg
2023 arXiv v1 (

@ Medium)

Heart Sound Classification
2013
2023 [2LSTM+3FC, 3CONV+2FC] [NRC-Net] [Log-MelSpectrum + Modified VGGNet] [CNN+BiGRU] [CWT+MFCC+DWT+CNN+MLP] [LSTM U-Net (LU-Net)]
==== My Other Paper Readings Are Also Over Here ====

  • Most review works about heart sound analysis were given before 2017, the present survey is the first to work on a comprehensive overview to summarise papers on heart sound analysis with deep learning in the past six years 2017–2022.

Outline

  1. Categories
  2. DL-Based Classification Models
  3. Datasets
  4. Future Directions

1. Categories

Categories
  • There are multiple hierarchical categories for heart sound classification research.

Most of the deep learning methods are focusing on the classification models.

2. DL-Based Classification Models

Classification Models
  • As it is challenging to extract effective representations from raw heart sound signals, 2D time-frequency representations have been widely used as the input of 2D CNNs for heart sound classification, respectively [29], [39], [42], [49], [50], [61], [72], [73], [76], [77], [81], [115]–[119].
  • 1D time-domain features can be also fed into DL models for heart sound classification.
  • Typical DL models on ImageNet, such as AlexNet [135] and VGG [136], have been successfully used for heart sound classification [8], [31], [44], [137].
  • In [138], pre-trained Audio Neural Networks (PANNs) trained on AudioSet were used for classifying heart sounds with inputs of time-frequency representations.
Hand-Crafted Features
  • The above tables show the research works working on Hand-Crafted Features.

3. Datasets

Datasets
  • The above table shows the available datasets.

4. Future Directions

  • Compared to models without segmentation information, segmentation did not significantly improve the model performance in the experiments [149].
  • There are also many approaches which proposed to use non-segmented heart sounds, therefore, the complexity of automated auscultation can be reduced [10], [44], [52], [90], [115].
  • There are a few studies of hardware working on automated diagnosis more recently.
  • The current research studies are mostly based on heart sounds only, while many types of individual information such as age can affect model performance [152].
  • In terms of ML and DL, we are currently witnessing the advent and adoption of foundation models [153] which can be potentially used for heart sound classification.
  • Human-machine classification can be a solution to combine both machines’ predictions and human’s (crowd workers’ and experts’) predictions for more precise diagnosis [154].
  • (Please kindly read the paper directly for more details.)

--

--

Sik-Ho Tsang

PhD, Researcher. I share what I learn. :) Linktree: https://linktr.ee/shtsang for Twitter, LinkedIn, etc.